Getting it Wrong, Surviving and Composting Failure
A homily prepared for the Spiritual Feast September 6, 2026
Why are we so afraid of falling when falling is all we've ever done?
In college, I made my childhood-favorite dessert for a dear friend, grasshopper pie, roughly the sweetest sugarbomb ever assembled. I knew she was diabetic. I knew it, and somewhere in the making I let myself forget. When I handed it to her and watched her face gently tell me she couldn't eat a bite, I fell. Not to the floor. But I felt the drop in my stomach, the heat in my face... the particular shame of getting it wrong in front of someone I loved.
I carried that one a long time as evidence against myself. Most of us keep a private ledger of the times we got it wrong, and somewhere we started mistaking the ledger for the truth about who we are.
But here is what the ledger forgets.
You are an expert faller. You have been falling your whole life, and you have survived every single one.
Consider how you learned to walk. Researchers who followed toddlers through one ordinary hour found they take over two thousand steps and fall seventeen times in that hour— crossing nearly eight football fields, going down again and again. And here is the part that babies know and we adults seem to forget: after a fall, the average baby is back in the play within two seconds. No shame. No ledger. The fall is not an interruption of the learning. The fall is the learning.
Because walking is not the opposite of falling. Walking is controlled falling. Every step tips your weight forward into empty air, into the beginning of a fall, and then catches it. Fall-and-catch. Fall-and-catch.
Now, for some of us, falling is not a metaphor. My friend who lives with cerebral palsy, sometimes using a scooter, sometimes a cane, falls often, and in public. Bystanders gather, with varying degrees of helpfulness and distress, and reach in to fix it. So my friend has learned to say, right away: "I'm an expert faller. I know how to do this. If you want to help, please listen to me, and we can do this together."
Hold what that teaches. The one who falls is not the one who failed. The one who falls is the one who has gained expertise. And help that arrives without consent is not help, it is someone else's distress landing on your body. Falling well is not falling alone; it is staying sovereign in the fall, and being caught only on terms you can say yes to.
And it isn't only babies and bodies that fall. The place where you are is falling right now, through space, around a sun that is itself falling through the galaxy. We can think of an orbit as falling and continually missing the ground. Gravity, the very thing that holds you to the Earth and the Earth to its star, is a fall that never lands. Falling is not the exception to belonging. Falling is the shape of it. It really is all we've ever done.
So why the fear? Some of it we were taught. We were handed a scoreboard, one straight line from failure to success, and told our worth is our place on it. But whose line is it? There is a name for refusing that straight, narrow ladder of success. Jack Halberstam calls it the queer art of failure: the freedom of declining to win a rigged game. Sometimes getting it wrong means we got their rules wrong on purpose.
And here I want to be careful. There is a fall we choose, the risk, the experiment, the honest try, and there is a fall done to us: the push, the trap, the system built so some of us cannot win. Faithfulness never tells the person who was failed that it was for their own good. It sits with them in the ditch and does not rush the rising. Getting it wrong is one kind of falling, but not every fall means we got something wrong.
But the falls that are ours, those compost.
Nothing in a forest is wasted; the fallen leaf becomes next season's soil.
My grasshopper pie was a fall, a fail, and it fed something. I did not become hopeful about gifts. I became faithful to the people I give them to. I learned to ask, to notice, to give what can actually be received. That failure made me a better lover of my friends than any success ever could.
That is the promise: not that we will stop falling, but that falling has never once been the end of us.
This Spiritual Feast series is ©2026 Amy Beltaine, all rights reserved. You may freely reprint any blog post, website, or print resource. Simply include the following attribution, and if you print online, make the link at the end live:
Article ©2026 Amy Beltaine, all rights reserved. Reprinted with permission. This article and hundreds of others, along with other free resources are available at http://www.AmyBeltaine.com
No comments:
Post a Comment