A Sacred Container of Kindness with Structure

Power exists in every relationship. In spiritual companionship, it’s essential to acknowledge that power — not to misuse or ignore it, but to hold it with intention and care. Pretending the relationship is fully equal can actually create harm, especially when the explorer is vulnerable or unsure of the process.

Ethical companionship means naming and carrying the responsibility that comes with holding space. We don’t dominate or dictate — but we also don’t disappear. The seeker is not looking for control, but for a steady presence: someone who can offer a sacred container where openness is paired with structure, and freedom is framed with kindness.

The relationship between a helper or spiritual caregiver and the person being companioned isn’t a democracy. In fact, trying to give away the power and responsibility that comes with the companion’s role can lead to the explorer feeling abandoned. Often, what the seeker truly needs is hospitality with structure — a compassionate vessel to hold their journey.

I often see a kind of over-correction — in couples, in spiritual companioning, and in well-intentioned attempts to be kind. Someone wants to be generous, open, and non-controlling… but ends up avoiding responsibility altogether.

We don’t want to dominate or control, so we don’t offer structure at all. We say things like:

“Whatever you want, dear.”
“What would you like to talk about today?”
“Well, it’s really up to you.”

And those phrases sound kind. But in many moments, they leave the other person feeling… a bit lost. Or even abandoned.

This has me reflecting deeply on what spiritual companionship and leadership require. Sometimes, in our desire to avoid control or hierarchy, we swing so far toward “letting it unfold” that we leave people untethered. Spaciousness becomes vagueness. Non-directiveness becomes abandonment disguised as kindness.

While the explorer (or seeker) might say they want openness, there are moments when they’re actually asking:

“Can you help hold me while I find my way?”

“Whatever You Want, Dear”: Over-Accommodating in Relationships

You’ve probably seen this dynamic: one person in a couple tries to be accommodating by never naming a preference. They say things like, “Whatever you want, dear,” or “I’m fine with anything.” And while that might seem polite, it can become maddening.
Because sometimes, what the other person really wants is partnership. Co-creation. Someone else to carry the load of decision-making. The unspoken question underneath may be:

“Can you help hold this moment with me?”

That kind of passivity — even when well-meaning — shifts all the responsibility onto the other person. And over time, it erodes connection.

Spiritual Companioning with New Explorers: Structure is Care

In a first or early spiritual direction session, the explorer may have no idea what this work can be. Maybe they signed up because they’re seeking, or someone recommended it, or it just felt right.

As a companion, if I open with “So what would you like to talk about today?” — I might be offering freedom. But I might also be offering fog.
If someone is unsure what spiritual companioning is, one of the kindest things we can do is to name the possibilities and offer a gentle framework:

“Some people bring a recent experience or feeling they want to explore more deeply. Others start with a dream, a decision, or even just a longing they can’t quite name. Would any of those feel supportive to you today?”

That’s not directive in the sense of control. It’s inviting with structure. It’s a form of hospitality.

When the Companion Has a Suggestion: Leadership with Consent

There are also moments when I, as a companion, feel an inner nudge to offer something — a question, a practice, an image from a tradition, a shift in focus.
This isn’t “telling the seeker what to do.” It’s offering a possible path with spaciousness and care. The difference is in tone and consent:

“I have something arising I’d like to offer — a possible thread we could explore together. Would you like to hear it?”

Even in mutual models like Anam Cara, where roles alternate and shared presence is central, spiritual direction isn’t a democracy.

It’s a sacred container, one held with intention and awareness. And containers — to be safe — need shape.

Timbisha Shoshone food/presentation bowl CC0

Particular Focus: When Non-Directiveness Isn’t Loving

In spiritual direction, we’re often trained to hold silence, to wait, to mirror back. That’s beautiful, and often exactly what’s needed.
But not always.

Sometimes, a question like “What would feel supportive to you right now?” isn’t as kind as simply offering:

“Would it be helpful if I named a few ways people navigate this?”

When someone is floundering, we can discern whether they need a mirror to reflect their own knowing — or a lifeline to steady them until they find their footing.

That’s not directive in the controlling sense. It’s offering structure with consent — meeting the seeker’s need with care, not control.

That structure is often what allows them to re-center, rather than drift away.

Try It: Reflect on These Questions

Have you ever hesitated to offer guidance for fear of being too directive? What happened?
What helps you know when a seeker wants choice versus when they need structure?
In group settings, how do you hold shared leadership while still offering direction and care?

Leading with consent and hospitality doesn’t mean abdicating your role. True presence includes noticing when structure is needed and offering it without control. That’s part of the sacred trust we carry — not to steer someone’s journey, but to help hold the vessel as they navigate it. When we honor the power that comes with this role and offer it with transparency, kindness, and humility, we create a space where seekers can rest, risk, and return to their own deep knowing.

Beloved, you are whole, holy, and worthy,

Rev. Amy

For Further Exploration

Silver, Mark. Heart of Business Newsletter – Offers wise reflections on the intersection of spirituality, leadership, and responsibility. https://www.heartofbusiness.com/newsletter/
Palmer, Parker. Let Your Life Speak – A beautiful meditation on vocation and how true guidance supports the soul’s unfolding. https://www.amazon.com/Let-Your-Life-Speak-Listening/dp/0787947350
Bowen, Murray. Family Therapy in Clinical Practice – Offers foundational insights on systems theory and how groups need clarity to avoid anxiety. https://www.amazon.com/Family-Therapy-Clinical-Practice-Classics/dp/0765700781

MoonForestBone

Sunday, April 20, 2025

When Spaciousness Feels Like Abandonment: On Being Directive Enough